Now to be fair, we did try letting him cry it out once or twice, but my heart just couldn't take it. Matthew was working nights during this time, so I was on my own with the crying it out and I just couldn't do it. So, I took the easy way out and let him nurse so that we all could sleep.
So the following night (we decided not to start that same day... he just had his shots and was feeling a bit under the weather and I didn't want to add to that) we decided to just do it! The first night he cried for about 30 minutes. So hard... I thought I was going to start crying. The second night....45 minutes. What?? Why are we going backwards, I thought this was suppose to get easier. Then the third night... he cried for over an hour. My strong and determined little boy!! By the fourth night, he talked for less than 15 minutes. Crying was over! Thank you God!!
We are now 12 days into our new routine and I have to admit that letting him Cry It Out worked. He is sleeping so much better and deeper these days. Not every night is perfect. He still wakes up around 330 every once in awhile, but he doesn't get to eat. I walk in, make sure he's okay (is he cold, warm, in pain...the normal momma checks) tell him I love him and then walk back out the door. He fusses or talks for a bit and then back to sleep he goes.
****Updated info as of 4/16: We are now 5 nights straight of sleeping fully through the night between 11 and 12 hours! It seems that our efforts have worked!****
I think the part that amazes me most about being a mom.... We sometimes learn the best lessons from our children. Thank you Jackson for teaching your momma to be just as stubborn and strong-willed as you are.